, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

4.19. As a major donor it is normal that the Commission should be closely involved with the definition of the programme or its partners, and should be able to influence priorities. The FPA conditions for this type of contract should be precise about narrative and financial reports - form and content - that will be supplied at the level of the partner's whole programme, so that the partner is sufficiently accountable to its donors. Also, such contracts should include audit arrangements for the operation as a whole, to avoid the situation where each donor seeks to apply its own audit requirements in isolation.

4.20. In order for this to be effective, other major donors would need to agree on a similar approach, which is unlikely to be easy. Nevertheless, the Commission and the Member States of the EU are in a position to take a lead in this area. The Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda made specific recommendations to donors, agencies and the OECD/DAC on the need to define 'consistent standards, including adequate breakdown of data by activity and area, for the humanitarian assistance community as a whole.. . . Donors have a responsibility to standardize among themselves the formats they use for reporting requirements of agencies to whom they provide funding` (51).

4.21. Differentiation of the contractual terms of the FPA on the lines set out above implies a degree of differentiation by groups of organizations with which the Commission works. One group consists of the major UN agencies and the ICRC, with whom particular agreements are needed both because of operations financed, and because of their particular multilateral and international status (see paragraph 2.23). A second group consists of the NGOs operating on an international scale, with medium or long-term programmes of humanitarian assistance in a given country, for which they obtain funding from several sources. A third group consists of NGOs which implement individual humanitarian actions, normally on a limited scale and with simple financing formulas.

The personnel costs of projects

4.22. Frequently, personnel expenses constitute a major part of the costs of a project. Unlike the purchase of goods and materials, where ECHO requires details of actual costs, a system of flat rates (52) is used, with different rates for expatriate and local personnel. As currently applied, the system suffers the following problems: