, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.28. In Kenya, an NGO obtained financing to provide medical assistance to Somali refugees in the Kilifi District. The assistance involved rehabilitation of the hospital, in particular the surgical facilities. The ECHO evaluator observed that the priority need was, however, for basic health care through health posts and the outpatients department. The outcome of the project was poor.

5.29. In former Yugoslavia, ECHO played the role of promoter in responding to a new but essential need that was identified for the provision of psychosocial assistance to war-traumatized women. It committed and funded projects by specialized NGOs in this area and much pioneering work was done, coordinated through the ECTF in Zagreb.

5.30. One of the evaluation criteria of the OECD Development Assistance Committee to be applied to humanitarian aid operations is to assess whether they contribute to the establishment of sustainable programmes of rehabilitation and development. Where humanitarian aid is being provided in situations of conflict this may not be feasible, at least initially, the humanitarian aid being directed simply towards the relief of suffering. This was the case in Bosnia-Herzegovina in 1992-94, and in Rwanda in 1994. However, even in these situations it is necessary to try to move beyond the provision of emergency relief as soon as possible. Since the mandate of ECHO was widened in January 1993 to include the provision of humanitarian aid of a non-urgent kind, this issue is particularly important. Humanitarian aid can address the symptoms, but not the causes of a humanitarian crisis. The effectiveness of the aid may be impaired by underlying structural problems (for example, a lack of development, economic or political transition, mismanagement) unless the relief component is accompanied by measures designed to address the structural weaknesses. The European Community must thus make every possible effort to support the introduction of such measures.