, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.44. The evaluations carried out by consultants on behalf of ECHO tend to be too geared towards assessing individual projects, even where the latter are clearly part of wider programmes jointly financed with other donors (see paragraph 5.3). Only in very few cases do they cover the operations conducted by ECHO itself. This being so, it is particularly difficult to draw overall conclusions and the advantages gained from these evaluation exercises do not emerge clearly in the course of subsequent operations. Indeed, the existing feedback mechanism does not work sufficiently well to enable the lessons learned from the evaluations to be taken into account in a generalized manner when new aid measures are introduced. However, the use of the evaluation manual recently drawn up by ECHO should make it possible to draw greater benefit from past experience (see paragraph 5.4).

5.45. Partners seldom provide ECHO with clear parameters and indicators on the basis of which their performances and the impact of their action can be monitored and assessed (see paragraphs 3.13, 5.3, 5.13-5.14, 5.26, 5.33).

5.46. In order to increase the independence of the evaluation functions, it would be preferable for the Commission to establish an evaluation service outside the operational departments which would cover humanitarian aid, rehabilitation and development activities. This would also help in the establishment of more transparent procedures for the selection of consultants than at present.

6.

OVERALL CONCLUSION

6.1. The Court has organized its audit around four main aspects (see paragraph 1.12) corresponding to questions relating to the clarity of the European Union's policy on humanitarian aid, the consistency and complementarity of the instruments which are implemented, the appropriateness of the means in terms of the objectives of the planned aid measures and, lastly, the process of evaluating the effects of the measures and reporting on their implementation. Whatever the regulatory, operational, administrative or financial difficulties encountered during this protracted period of reorganization, the European Union's contribution to the spirit of international solidarity is nevertheless a major phenomenon for which the Commission must take the credit.

Clarity of the European Union's policy on humanitarian aid