Despite declarations of intent, most of the Member States did not provide the contributions, and ECHO had to bear most of the running costs (5,62 Mio ECU between February 1992 and February 1996). As the Commission financed virtually all the running of the task force and as it was generally involved with its management, the ECTF in effect became the operational arm of ECHO in Croatia, Bosnia-Herzegovina and Slovenia. In doing so, the ECTF was generally perceived as an office of ECHO. According to an evaluation carried out by an external consultant, some of the Member State representatives did not understand the role of the ECTF, nor how it related to ECHO.>END OF GRAPHIC>
2.22. During the period covered by the Court's inquiries, coordination essentially took place at central level, at the quarterly meetings arranged by ECHO, in response to a Council Resolution (30), between the directors of the national humanitarian aid services. However, the minutes of these meetings show that the coordination had little concrete effect in the short term. Firstly, it consisted in providing the Member States with information on Commission financing decisions and the implementation of them. Then, it served to initiate discussion of various questions of principle, such as relations with the United Nations agencies. Some specific questions were also raised. On every occasion the Member States' representatives closed up whenever there was a possibility of anything more than an exchange of views, and suggestions for studies or coordinated action were referred to higher authority (see paragraph 1.10(c)). During the period 1992-1995, the Member States which systematically informed ECHO of their own humanitarian measures were the exception. This being so, unless there is a radical change in behaviour, there can be no extension of coordinated action between the European Union and the Member States because of the lack of adequate commitment on the part of the authorities in the latter.
Cooperation with the United Nations and international organizations