, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

4.46. The nature of humanitarian operations makes expenditure forecasting an arbitrary matter and it is not unusual for advances paid by the Commission to exceed actual expenditure. In these cases, ECHO is obliged to recover the surplus funds at the time of final settlement. Several months elapse between the winding-up of the file and the issue of a recovery order, even when the partner states that it is prepared to refund the amount quickly.

Conclusion

4.47. In view of the scale of recent crises and the absence of adequate redeployment of staff by the Commission, ECHO has been obliged to make extensive use of temporary staff (see paragraphs 4.4-4.7). The rules and practices regarding the conditions of recruitment and employment of the staff of Community institutions are ill-suited to the demands of humanitarian operations. The current rigidity of the system has a paralysing effect (see paragraphs 4.4-4.10).

4.48. The framework partnership agreement has proved to be a useful administrative tool. In its present form, however, it is of limited use for steering, controlling and monitoring the extent to which the partners contribute to the priorities and objectives adopted by the Commission and is not suited for all organizations (international organizations, large NGOs, small NGOs). For making the tool more effective, a differentiation of such contracts according to the different types of partners would be necessary (see paragraphs 4.17-4.21 and 1.3).

4.49. The evaluation of partners' procedures and management systems is an area in which ECHO must continue to make an effort.

4.50. In two cases involving consignments of foodstuffs and supplies the procurement procedures were defective. In the case of family packages, the sums which could have been charged to the Commission unduly may have amounted to several million ecus (see paragraph 4.26).

4.51. Whereas ECHO scrupulously verifies the financial accounts when settling expenditure, evaluation of the actual implementation of work programmes and the results obtained by its partners were subject only to limited checks, even when the reports submitted were extremely terse or vague (see paragraphs 4.28-4.34 and 4.40).