, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.25. The provision of the means for beneficiaries to produce food for themselves - e.g. seeds, agricultural tools, fishing tackle - is also a highly appropriate response, encouraging self-sufficiency. The few problems identified in Angola concern such matters as poor quality or incorrect specification of the procured tools or late delivery of seeds so that the sowing season was missed.

5.26. In the medical field, weaknesses in the precise identification of needs or the lack of coordination between different organizations have led on occasions to the supply of inappropriate goods. These cases highlight the necessity for NGOs to improve their needs evaluations, and for ECHO to improve its vetting of proposals (see paragraph 3.13). In the majority of cases examined, however, the goods or services provided in the medical field were appropriate.

5.27. In former Yugoslavia, as a component of a project to supply various relief supplies to Bosnia and Serbia in the winter of 1992/93, an NGO obtained 2 Mio ECU from ECHO to provide surgical kits for hospitals in Serbia and the Bosnian Serb parts of Bosnia. No evaluation of needs was carried out by the NGO on the spot in advance, the assessment was done at headquarters, and was not coordinated with the UNHCR, the lead agency. An ex post evaluation commissioned by the NGO itself found that, in Bosnia, surgical materials were delivered to hospitals where there were in fact numerous wounded and where the needs were great, but the kits covered basic needs only and should have been followed rapidly by more targeted material. There was no justification for spending so much on basic kits. There was, however, great need for basic medicines, which, though costing much less than the surgical material, had been omitted from the project. Other components of this operation (e.g.: food, hygienics, blankets) were in important respects also inappropriate. In Serbia, the hospitals, after having expressed their needs by responding to a questionnaire, simply collected from the warehouses of the NGO the materials they wanted, without any check on their real requirements.