4.33. As far as operations implemented by NGOs are concerned, there is a widespread recognition amongst the major organizations of the need for rigorous self-monitoring both by field staff and headquarters, but performance remains variable. Inadequacies in initial preparation of projects, with poorly defined objectives and action programmes (see paragraph 3.13), make monitoring and reporting results difficult. The lack of definition by ECHO of what should be included in narrative reports is one reason why many narrative reports (more than 20 % of the 104 operations examined) provide little information about monitoring and what the project had achieved. Thus, even where there had been adequate monitoring, the reports did not show it.
4.34. The NGOs visited on the spot in Angola and former Yugoslavia were, in general, monitoring their projects closely and were able to present up-to-date information on implementation status. The situation at the headquarters of the NGOs visited was variable, with some having only a general idea of activities on the ground, whereas others had full details, and staff from headquarters visited the actions on the ground fairly frequently (62).
Monitoring by the Commission
4.35. ECHO relies to a large extent on its technical assistants in the field to monitor implementation by its partners (see paragraphs 4.8 and 4.9). Their effectiveness is varied: in Croatia and Serbia the technical assistants in the ECTF and ECHO Belgrade working with NGOs were experienced and well accepted. They were in frequent contact with the NGOs, visiting project sites, providing advice and assisting with new project proposals or changes to existing projects. They also participated in the coordination meetings with the UN agencies, NGOs and donors. In Angola, however, the situation was the opposite.