, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997
f)

since the operational contracts relate to measures which are complex or part of large-scale aid programmes, the set time-limits for the eligibility of expenditure are often too short and do not correspond to the real duration of the measures (49). In 41 % of the operational contracts which were examined, the contractual periods proved to be unsuited to the partners' constraints. For the convoys organized by the Danish Refugee Council in former Yugoslavia, ECHO, for example, made 25 agreements between June 1992 and September 1994. Even though this may be an extreme case, it shows that where the duration of the contracts is insufficient, this complicates the planning and management of the aid measures and thus leads to loss of effectiveness and unnecessary costs;

g)

expenditure is not finally settled until a narrative report on the implementation of the measure has been submitted. However, whilst the financial statements of costs are subject to very strict checks on their compliance with the budgets or as regards the dates of issue of the invoices, in none of the cases examined during the audit was it found that ECHO's departments had sought explanations when the reports were too vague or else too brief for the real extent of the implementation of the work programme to be judged (50).

Box 2 - Application of the framework partnership agreement to the UNHCR

>START OF GRAPHIC>

The main observations arising from an examination of the agreements made in respect of the aid measures in former Yugoslavia for 237 Mio ECU are as follows:

a)

ECHO did not make any general contribution to the UNHCR's action programmes, but financed individual measures within these programmes. In practice, ECHO links its financing more to pre-determined measures than do the other donors. This practice is ill-suited to UNHCR's mode of operation and creates grave administrative and accounting difficulties for the UNHCR, because the financing is so brief and unpredictable in the medium term;

b)

because of the war situation, the UNHCR's estimates of needs for equipment and provisions have remained very rough and have included the setting-up of reserve stocks in order to cope with contingencies. For its part, despite being represented on the spot, ECHO has often been unable to assess the validity of the requests submitted by the UNHCR;