although the term used is 'flat rates`, and in practice ECHO pays the standard rates in full, it has tried to argue (53) that what is in fact meant is that the 'flat rates` are ceilings up to which payments will be made;
the remuneration actually paid by ECHO's partners to their staff varies considerably: for some, the flat rates are insufficient to cover the costs (e.g. the UN agencies, international organizations and some NGOs which pay near-professional rates), while for others, whose staff work for volunteer rates, the flat rate sometimes exceeds actual costs substantially (54);
the rates for local personnel are also standardized across the world, and are based on the levels of pay in the poorest countries (55). They are totally inappropriate for middle-income countries such as former Yugoslavia. A majority of the partners contacted considered the local flat rates far too low to enable them to appoint good local staff, especially in highly-qualified professional categories. In these circumstances, there is an incentive for partners to appoint expatriate personnel rather than local staff, which penalizes both the country in crisis and the budget of the Community.
Standardization of contract terms and conditions
4.23. The Commission has not standardized its contractual terms and conditions for its partners receiving funds for humanitarian aid actions managed by ECHO (governed by the FPA), food aid operations managed by DG VIII (the Official Letters), refugee programmes managed by DG 1B and DG VIII (letter contracts), and the co-financing of development projects with NGOs, managed by DG VIII (letter contracts). About 45 % of the ECHO partners consulted pointed out that they did not understand the reasons for the considerable variation in procedures. While it is true that contract formats, terms and conditions cannot be strictly identical for the different types of action financed, there is scope for considerable standardization and improved coherence between the requirements of the Commission's different departments, notably in the following areas:
payment conditions (for example, advances, conditions for release of funds);
other financial conditions, including treatment of interest (56), payment of flat-rate amounts for personnel or transport;
procurement rules;
inspection and surveillance;
transport and delivery conditions;