, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.13. In 1993, ECHO allocated 2,8 Mio ECU to the German Red Cross (DRK) to provide food products for young children in Armenia. The project was, however, poorly prepared. The DRK did not know what products were needed nor in what quantities. No prior decision had been taken concerning transport, a key element, and it was not clear whether the Armenian Red Cross had the capacity to distribute the food. There were no detailed distribution plans and the impact of winter on distribution was not considered. In August 1994, six months after the end of the contract, stocks of goods remained to be distributed.

5.14. ECHO should require clear evidence in the proposals from partners that they have carried out a proper assessment of needs and identified who are the intended beneficiaries (see paragraph 3.13). It should also insist that partners indicate whether other agencies/ organizations are working in the same sector in the same area, and if so, how the partner will ensure that its activities are coordinated with those of the other agencies/organizations. Where appropriate, evidence should be provided that both the needs and the beneficiaries identified have been compared with those contained in any UN Inter-Agency Appeal and any disparities explained. ECHO coordinators on the spot should play a key role in assessing this, as staff in Brussels are too far away from the scene of the operations to be able to do this thoroughly.

Delivery

5.15. Paragraphs 4.28 to 4.34 present observations concerning the monitoring carried out by both the UN agencies and NGOs implementing actions financed by ECHO. Poor monitoring and control over distributions, notably of food and medical supplies, mean that it is not possible to know with any certainty whether the aid has reached the beneficiaries.

5.16. In Serbia and Croatia, where food and hygienics supplies were distributed to refugees and displaced persons in organized centres, and where there were few problems of security, it was possible to carry out detailed control on distributions. The overwhelming bulk of the aid reached those to whom it was directed.