, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.5. Further, there is a need for the Commission to consider integrating the evaluation of humanitarian aid with the evaluation of other external policies financed and managed by the Commission. Currently there is an Evaluation Unit in DG VIII responsible for the evaluation of development and rehabilitation activities financed from the general budget and from the European Development Funds, and the evaluation unit in ECHO. The OECD Development Assistance Committee (DAC) has pointed to the need to extend evaluation activities to all external aid activities of the Commission (i.e. including operations managed by the EIB under mandate from the Commission, and the PHARE and TACIS programmes). It has also observed that the DAC Principles on evaluation require a high degree of independence for the evaluation function, which would be best achieved by having the evaluation service outside the administrative units (DGs, Office) responsible for operations. Combining the existing evaluation units in a department, e.g. within the Secretariat-General, would both enhance the independence of the function and help to ensure the most concentrated and effective use of evaluation resources.

Effectiveness of humanitarian assistance

5.6. The following paragraphs summarize the information obtained from various sources - examination of contract files, on-the-spot visits, review of ECHO's evaluation reports, other evaluations and reports - concerning the effectiveness of the Commission's humanitarian assistance, in particular that managed by ECHO.

Coverage

Targeting

5.7. The assessment of the total numbers of persons requiring humanitarian assistance, and their whereabouts, particularly in the context of major crises, is generally carried out by the UN agencies, for example as part of the consolidated appeal process. They seek help and information from all appropriate sources: the local authorities, NGOs and others. By expanding its presence on the spot during the major crises, ECHO has increasingly put itself in a position both to participate in the assessment process and to evaluate more critically the assessments that are made (see paragraph 3.22).