3.13. In respect of the operations examined for the period 1992-1995, partners were not required by ECHO to provide precise information on the objectives and scope of the proposed actions and the targeted beneficiaries, but mainly to provide a list of personnel, supplies and services for which they were seeking financial support (see paragraph 4.14). In contrast with the procedures followed by the Commission departments prior to the establishment of ECHO, Commission delegation staff on the spot were not required to comment on these proposals systematically. The process of appraisal by ECHO staff in Brussels was reduced primarily to the choice of items that ECHO was willing to finance, but the files contained little information relating to the appraisal of requests or to the reasons for modifications to proposals, which sometimes seemed hard to justify (41). In 74 of the 104 projects examined by the Court, the way in which the project file had been prepared could not be clearly established.
3.14. Seven NGOs (which between them received 19 % of all funds allocated to NGOs during the period from 1992-1995) considered that greater attention needed to be paid to the pertinence and content of the proposed action. This is confirmed by several of the consultants contracted by ECHO to evaluate individual operations (see paragraph 5.12). At the end of 1995, ECHO tightened up its procedures for appraising its operations.
3.15. Furthermore, at the time of the Court's audit in 1995 ECHO had no criteria or organized records of previous experience with which it could determine the relevance of the action and the competence and efficiency of the potential partner (see paragraph 4.15 a). The files examined contained little or no evidence of why certain implementing partners were chosen rather than others. In paragraphs 5.22 to 5.28 of this report, the consequences of the inadequate initial preparation are set out. The revised procedures introduced in autumn 1995 whereby ECHO staff are required to document the preparation, follow-up and appreciation of each action should enable better targeting.
Co-financing