, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

3.5. In commenting on the Food Aid and Rehabilitation Aid programme in Azerbaijan between 1992 and 1995, a consultant engaged by ECHO pointed out that no comprehensive strategy had been defined and that the programme was a compilation of the requests of NGOs and other organizations working in Azerbaijan. ECHO's strategy paper 'Transcaucasus Humanitarian Assistance Strategy 1995` was seen by the consultant as an important step in establishing a sound strategy.

3.6. In former Yugoslavia, although broad objectives were identified for the proposed decisions, these were too general to constitute a precise strategy. For example, in the Commission decision of 100 Mio ECU of June 1993, the aims were to provide aid in the various regions (39), but without identifying the target beneficiaries in terms of status (40), nationality or geographical location, nor their needs and how these were being met by other organizations. The document did not define the EU policy towards the UN agencies or the ECTF (see Box 1), nor did it mention the existence of any privileged partners. Similar comments apply to the objectives set out in the decision of 156 Mio ECU of November 1994, where one of the objectives was to fund urgent rehabilitation activities, without these having been defined or located, despite the existence of the IMG-IBH which the Commission had already been financing since the end of 1993 (see endnote 33).

3.7. When the Commission adopts global plans, the NGOs' proposals for projects (see paragraph 3.1) may be put aside for several months before being included in series of financing decisions, for reasons relating to the decision-making process. The partners often see this practice as a source of complication: 45 % of the NGOs which replied to the Court's questionnaire (see paragraph 1.14) took this view.

Internal coordination of the Commission's aid measures

3.8. Several administrative departments of the Commission are involved in (see paragraph 3.12), and several sources of funding are available for, similar or related actions (see paragraphs 3.10 and 3.11). The UN agencies and many NGOs obtain funds under different Commission programmes, managed by different departments: