, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.17. In Croatia, ECHO, through the ECTF (see Box 1), successfully delivered food to refugees and displaced persons numbering between 300 000 and 400 000 in 103 distribution centres. There were some problems resulting from uneven delivery of commodities, but generally the operations were managed efficiently and well evaluated. Similarly, in Serbia, where ECHO supplied a range of commodities to supplement the basic foodstuffs provided by the WFP, operations were conducted efficiently and effectively.

5.18. In Bosnia, however, where the security situation made close monitoring dangerous, supplies were delivered to the municipalities and various organizations responsible for distribution. In the main, those who needed the assistance received it, although it is recognized that those involved in the hostilities also received a share. In order that the UNHCR could keep supplies moving into the Muslim Bosnian enclaves, it also made deliveries to the displaced Bosnian Serbs.

5.19. In the Rwandan refugee camps in Tanzania and Zaire, as the Hutu army and Militia were mixed in with the refugees, it proved impossible to prevent them too from receiving humanitarian assistance.

5.20. In Angola, the Commission was in conflict with the WFP because the latter was unable to provide satisfactory and complete information about the distribution of food aid. The food was distributed to beneficiaries by various NGOs, but the reporting and data-collection procedures were poor, so that subsequently the WFP had difficulties in providing the Commission with a satisfactory overall report.

5.21. Audit observations and the evaluations commissioned by ECHO show that, in most cases, the aid reaches those to whom it is intended, even if in many cases it arrives later than initially planned. A significant factor affecting the apparent late arrival of aid is that the timetable implied by the period of the contract is frequently unrealistic (see paragraph 4.15 (f)). Where the aid is part of a programme (e.g. food aid provided to the WFP), the late arrival of supplies under the ECHO contract may be compensated for by supplies from other donors. There have, however, been some cases where delays in procurement by the WFP have resulted in beneficiaries not receiving aid when they should have (e.g. in 1994: Transcaucasus, Tadjikistan and Kyrgyzstan).

Appropriateness