, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

3.16. The Court is not opposed to the principle of earmarking funds for specific expenditure (42). However, it has found on several occasions that operational contracts formed part of a wider programme which was also financed by other donors. Of the 104 operations examined by the Court, 32 were of this type. In the case of major humanitarian operations in which a small number of donors is involved, it would be desirable for them, together with the partners concerned, to adopt a harmonized approach when defining the programme, with regard to their respective financial contribution and the joint system of reporting, monitoring and control.

3.17. The audit showed that one NGO was granted 12,6 Mio ECU to cover the cost of medical interventions in Bosnia-Herzegovina in the period from July 1992 to September 1994 and that during the same period, the organization received other grants, without the Commission's knowledge, from the United Kingdom and the UNHCR, and also received conditional funding of 4 Mio HFL (1,85 Mio ECU (43)) from the Netherlands Cooperation to complement the funds provided by ECHO. The same organization received 2,1 Mio ECU for its intervention in Liberia for the period from May 1993 to August 1994, in addition to grants from other Member States.

3.18. In 1993 an NGO submitted a rehabilitation programme in Northern Iraq for funding, informing ECHO that it was seeking funds from other donors, including a Member State humanitarian aid agency. ECHO agreed to finance a large part of the programme, but not the roads component, which was outside its mandate. This component was, however, an essential element in the programme. The NGO managed to obtain the necessary additional funds from four other sources. ECHO, in its monitoring of the project, showed interest only in the financial execution of the components which it had financed. At the end of the programme, only one of the funding sources (another NGO) requested a narrative and financial report covering the whole programme, showing total income and total expenditure.

Conclusion