5.38. A necessary - though not always sufficient - procedure for ensuring cost-effective procurement is tendering, or at least adequate market testing. Generally, the large organizations apply adequate procedures for market testing, and seek to obtain the best offer in terms of price, delivery, reliability of supply, and similar criteria. The Commission should consider whether it would be expedient to introduce a single procurement and tendering system for humanitarian and food aid (see paragraphs 4.25-4.27).
5.39. With the rapid growth in humanitarian aid over the last five years, specialist suppliers, such as IDA (74), have emerged, with beneficial effects on cost-effectiveness.
5.40. Paragraph 4.22 shows that more attention needs to be paid to cost-effectiveness in the use of expatriate personnel. In the case of the supply of medical materials to Mongolia, the NGO employed four inexperienced expatriates. They received from their NGO 1 000 ECU/month, but ECHO provided 3 800 ECUmonth as a flat rate, and did not check real costs when making payments. One expatriate coordinator was needed, with local staff who would have been able to speak Mongolian and Russian. The cost-effectiveness of this operation was further reduced by unnecessary airfreighting of the medical supplies, as there was no emergency.
Visibility
5.41. Although 'visibility` of humanitarian assistance is not a criterion for judging the effectiveness of the assistance, it is a central goal for the Commission's approach as set out in its decision to establish ECHO. The Court's examination, therefore, has assessed whether the humanitarian aid operations financed by the Commission have been sufficiently visible to the beneficiaries and others in the recipient country, and especially to the European taxpayer.
5.42. The importance attached by the Commission to increasing the visibility of its humanitarian aid reflects a general policy to secure greater recognition amongst beneficiaries, and especially the European taxpayer, of EU programmes and policies. In the area of humanitarian aid ECHO has developed an information strategy involving all branches of the media, and joint visibility productions with major partners. The Commission decided to give a distinct logo to ECHO, and considerable attention is paid to the marking of humanitarian aid supplies with the logo and contract reference.