5.22. It is important to assess whether the aid provided was what the beneficiaries needed, in terms of the types of products supplied and, indeed, to evaluate whether the appropriate response to the problem was to provide humanitarian aid. Specifically, one of the questions that needs to be answered is whether the humanitarian assistance has contributed to a sustainable process of rehabilitation and recovery (see paragraph 5.30).
5.23. Generally, where food products are being supplied, the rations are appropriate, in terms of their nutritional component. Standards for basic rations and supplementary feeding have been laid down, to which the organizations involved try to adhere. The Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda identified an important problem with the supply of maize grain to refugees in Zaire, and particularly Tanzania. This commodity was known to be unfamiliar, and thus of low acceptability to the refugees. The WFP tried to take this into account when setting the ration for the refugees, and both it and the ICRC sought to obtain maize flour by encouraging their donors to supply it, or through regional purchasing. The WFP, however, had to accept whole-grain maize purchased locally in Tanzania because its donors were unwilling to provide funds to cover milling costs (71). The recipients of the maize grain either cooked it for extended periods to make it palatable, using substantially more fuel-wood than if it had been flour (72), or traded it on the local markets, notably for cassava, the main staple of the refugees. The terms of trade they were able to obtain implied a substantial loss of food energy. The Joint Evaluation concluded that the provision of a commodity which did not correspond to the dietary habits of the recipients reflected a substantial inefficiency on the part of the WFP and its donors.
5.24. In some locations, e.g. Mostar in Bosnia-Herzegovina, Bengo province in Angola, individual NGOs try to improve the diet by bringing in locally procured fresh fruit or fresh animal/fish protein. This is, however, generally on a small scale. Amongst the evaluations commissioned by ECHO is one, concerning a nutritional programme in Haiti, where the evaluator questions whether it was appropriate to distribute high-cost imported animal protein in tins.