provisions concerning the presentation of narrative and financial reports, including the deadlines specified.
4.24. The Commission has recognized that the application of different procedures, including contractual ones, in the administration of refugee programmes is unsatisfactory (57). In 1994, the Commission departments involved with refugee actions examined whether the FPA was applicable to their longer-term actions, but found that it was not. Since then, there has been little progress towards harmonization of contractual conditions. The review of the terms and conditions of the FPA by the Commission should explicitly take this into account.
Tendering
4.25. Generally, it was found that the large organizations, such as the UN agencies, the ICRC, the large NGOs, apply appropriate procedures for market-testing and tendering, and seek to obtain the best offers in terms of price, delivery, reliability of supply, and similar criteria. These organizations, including the large NGOs, generally have specialized procurement departments and keep their procedures under review.
4.26. With regard to the procedures followed by the Commission, out of 20 operations examined by the Court (58) those carried out by two organizations showed procedures which fell short of what should be expected:
the first case concerns contracts for the supply of food parcels to Serbia. Although this was in practice a direct operation of ECHO - ECHO Belgrade was responsible for the distribution of the parcels -, the funds were passed to an NGO which purchased the food parcels from a supplier without tendering. It was not until the fourteenth contract, in May 1994, that a competitive procedure was followed, and the supplier reduced the price of the supplies by 16 % and that of the transport by 37 % (59). In this case, the Commission should have been more active in ensuring proper competitive tendering from the outset;
in the case of supplies of seeds and agricultural tools to Angola, the way in which the ECHO staff issued a call for tenders made it impossible to make a valid comparison of the bids received, with the result that contracts were several times awarded to the same supplier. Where the size of contracts makes it necessary for performance to be spread over several months it is impossible for urgency to be cited as justification for direct negotiations. Discipline must be improved in this area.