, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
23.

The Court identified serious irregularities and shortcomings in financial management in the way in which the MED programmes have been organized and implemented. These were brought to the attention of the Commission as soon as possible because of the need for immediate action to be taken to correct the highly unsatisfactory situation that was found. Following discussions with the Commissioner and Commission services concerned, the Court was informed at the end of November 1995 of a number of measures the Commission intended to take (see paragraph 57).

24.

The criticisms set out in this report are not directed at the concept of decentralized cooperation. It is the way in which it has been implemented that is unsatisfactory. The shortcomings identified, however, must be overcome if the concept itself is not to be called into question.

OVERALL SYSTEM FOR MANAGING THE PROGRAMMES

Summary

In the light of the inadequacy of its own resources to manage the MED- programmes, the Commission subcontracted the administration and financial management to ARTM, a non-profit making organization established specifically for this task on the initiative of the Commission. The technical monitoring functions were contracted out to Technical Assistance Offices (usually consulting firms). The manner in which this was done, and the subsequent functioning of these management arrangements gave rise to a number of serious irregularities and weaknesses in financial management:

–

the powers conferred upon ARTM constitute in effect a delegation of the powers of the Commission to a third party: apart from the fact that it is doubtful whether in this case there is a legal basis for such a delegation, a decision in principal to that effect is required, which can only be taken by the Commission itself. No such decision exists,

–

excessive recourse was had to private treaty contracts, without proper tendering,

–

the manner in which contracts were awarded, the involvement of the same consulting firms in the conception of the programmes, in the preparation of financing proposals, in the management of ARTM, and in the technical monitoring of the programmes led to a situation in which serious confusions of interest existed, prejudicial to the proper management of Community funds,