From the above it is apparent not only that the obligations specified in the contracts signed with ARTM have been widely disregarded by the networks, but also that the financial documents on which the Commitment Committee bases its decisions are worthless in the strict accounting sense and offer no guarantee of reliability. It is also clear that the responsible staff of the Commission and ARTM were not aware of this. In the extreme case of the MED Campus 33 network, the coordinator not only did not keep the supporting documents, he did not keep any accounts either.
The obligations associated with the principle that projects are to be co-financed by the Commission and the members of the networks have been widely disregarded. The Annexes to the first contracts were particularly clear on this point. Before it paid the second instalment of the Community subsidy to the networks, ARTM was to check that the coordinator had mobilized the material, human and financial resources required of each member of the network (1). Checks by the Court showed that none of the MED-Campus networks was in a position to produce a decision of the board of directors concerning a subsidy award, still less by the coordinator organization or the other network members. As regards MED-Urbs, only one of the coordinating authorities, the town of Belfort, was able to produce to the Court the minutes of the municipal council meeting awarding a subsidy specifically to the MED-Urbs 31 network.
In practice, therefore, the participation of network members has usually been confined to providing material resources and making direct payment for some expenditure items. In the case of the latter it subsequently transpired that the amounts could not be verified because the network coordinators did not have the supporting documents for the amounts declared and were unable to obtain them from their associates. As a result, the European Community is usually the only backer. When confronted with this situation, the managers at ARTM and the Commission elected to amend the specimens of subsequent contracts to make the co-financing obligation more vague, instead of requiring network coordinators to fulfil their contractual obligations. In so doing, they abandoned one of the concepts on which the creation of the MED programmes was based.