, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996

SPECIAL REPORT No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission`s replies (96/C 240/01)

(submitted pursuant to Article 188C, paragraph 4, indent 2, of the EC Treaty)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Paragraph Page

INTRODUCTION... 1-24 3

Background... 1-4 3

Presentation of the MED programmes... 5-18 3

The diversity of the programmes... 7-18 3

Resources implemented... 19-20 4

A new legal framework and increased budgetary resources... 19-20 4

The Court`s methods and objectives... 21-24 5

OVERALL SYSTEM FOR MANAGING THE PROGRAMMES... 25-84 5

General presentation... 25-38 6

The ARTM... 25-27 6

The mechanism of the system... 28-38 6

Appraisal of applications... 28-30 6

Preparation and structure of the financing decisions... 31-38 6

Analysis of the system and of the way in which it functions... 39-84 7

Observations concerning the delegation of powers... 39-57 7

Legal basis... 41 7

Competent authority... 42-43 8

Conditions of delegation... 44-45 8

Rules for awarding public contracts... 46-49 8

Confusion of interests... 50-57 9

Budgetary and financial observations concerning the implementation of the programmes... 58-80 10

Rate of implementation of the budget... 58-60 10

Cost of managing the system... 61 10

Checks in respect of the ARTM`s financial data... 62-63 10

Regularity from the point of view of budgetary principles... 64-70 10

Administrative expenditure covered by operating appropriations... 64-65 10

Infringements of the budgetary principle of universality... 66-70 11

Incorrect presentation of the Community`s accounts... 71-72 11

Use of reserves... 73-74 11

Drawing up of the accounts... 75-76 12

Protection of the Commission`s financial interests... 77-80 12

Observations concerning selection procedures... 81-84 12

Establishment of the Committees... 81 12

Procedure for the selection of members... 82 12

Identifying needs... 83-84 12

PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION... 85-130 13

Introduction... 85-86 13

Results of audits at network head offices... 87-115 13

Findings concerning financial and accounting matters... 87-96 13

Ineligibility of some expenditure... 97-104 14

Reimbursement of staff expenditure... 98-100 15

Absence of supporting documents... 101 15

Other anomalies identified... 102-104 15

Observations on sound financial management... 105-108 16

Calls for tenders... 105 16

Amounts of subsistence allowances and additional remuneration... 106-108 16

The viability of the networks... 109 16

The impact of the projects... 110-115 16

The causes of this situation... 116-130 17