An analysis of the utilization of the appropriations under budget heading B 7-4 0 8 0, which was introduced into the budget by Regulation (EEC) No 1763/92, shows that, on 31 December 1994, a total of ECU 169,7 million was committed, on the basis of which ECU 62,4 million was disbursed.
Of these sums, the commitments corresponding to the implementation of the MED programmes amounted to ECU 75,8 million, of which ECU 23,9 million was committed in December 1994. A total of ECU 40,2 million (ECU 39,2 million to the ARTM and ECU 1,0 million in direct payments to TAOs and experts) was paid by the Commission from these commitments.
Annex 4 provides a detailed analysis of available funds and their use. That shows that out of the total available funds of ECU 40,9 million, ECU 33,3 million was disbursed, leaving ECU 7,6 million unused at 31 December 1994. This amount, which represented almost 20 % of the Commission`s payments to ARTM, was well in excess of the cash requirements for the programmes.
Cost of managing the system
Annex 4 also shows that, of the ECU 33,3 million paid out by ARTM, only ECU 26,9 million (80,8 %) was contributions to projects. The rest was used to pay for the services of ARTM itself (ECU 1,3 million) and the TAO`s (ECU 3,7 million) and to finance committees (ECU 0,3 million), conferences (ECU 0,1 million ) and evaluations (ECU 0,5 million). Another ECU 0,2 million for other costs and ECU 0,3 million for financing costs are overheads. These items, representing the costs necessary for the management of the programmes, total ECU 6,4 million, i.e. more than 19 % of funds actually used. These costs of actually managing the programmes do not include expenditure specific to the functioning of each of the networks subsidized.
Checks in respect of the ARTM`s financial data
The progress reports sent by the ARTM to the Commission are not based directly on its accounts but are drawn up on the basis of non-accounting data compiled from spreadsheets kept on computer by ARTM staff.
These non-accounting documents do not comply with the rules for submitting information which were observed in respect of the keeping of the ARTM`s accounts by an independent expert. The Court drew attention to a number of discrepancies between these two sources which should be analysed and regularly justified. The Court was unable to find any evidence that these comparisons had been made either by the ARTM or the Commission.