The Commission justified the awarding of contracts by private treaty (by way of derogation from Article 56 of the FR (1)) to the ARTM by citing the absence on the market of a body with the requisite qualifications. However, there is no evidence in the Commission`s files to show that the Management Department carried out any research in respect of the market in order to check the situation, and the fact that several candidates applied when the invitation to tender was issued in 1994 would seem to indicate that firms with these qualifications already existed at the time. Furthermore, in the Court`s opinion, the ARTM had no particular responsibilities either at the technical level or in terms of administrative and financial management which could have provided unrestricted justification for its being chosen.
Until December 1993, the contracts awarded to the BATs were also awarded by private treaty. The table in Annex 3 shows for the period concerned that, out of 12 contracts awarded, in more than half of the cases no invitation to tender had been issued.
Confusion of interests
Two of the four administrators of the ARTM were, until April 1995, also managers of the BATs (the firms FERE Consultants and Ismeri) responsible for monitoring the MED programmes.
These same BATs participated in the planning of the MED programmes, including the stage at which draft financing proposals were prepared, a task which is the exclusive responsibility of the Commission (2). In order to carry out this work, FERE Consultants, as part of the preparation of the MED-Urbs programmes and component B of the MED-Invest programme, and Ismeri Europa with regard to MED-Campus, obtained ECU 323 000 and ECU 199 960 respectively. These contracts were also awarded by direct negotiation with these bodies.
The conditions for awarding the contracts and the involvement of the same firms of consultants in preparing the programmes, drawing up financing proposals, on the Management Board of the ARTM and in monitoring the programmes resulted in a situation where there was a conflict of interests that was prejudicial to the sound management of Community funds and contrary to the principle of equality of access to public contracts. Two particularly serious cases must be highlighted: