, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
(c)

there is undoubted enthusiasm amongst the participants for the actions, where contacts between professionals in the same sector are developed: however, positive evaluations of meetings, seminars, and other actions by the participants do not necessarily mean that the activities have had the intended impact; more systematic evaluation is necessary;

(d)

as noted in paragraph 110, the sustainability of some of the networks when Commission support is withdrawn is doubtful.

115.

The impact of the MED programmes, therefore, remains to be proven. Even if the concept of decentralized cooperation of this sort may be innovative and attractive, it is essential that rigour should be applied in formulating objectives, in deciding how those objectives are to be achieved and measured and then in evaluating whether or not they have been achieved.

The causes of this situation 116. The causes of the situation described above are various. They consist not only of weaknesses in network management, but also of weaknesses in the planning of projects and the shortcomings of the monitoring tools.

Weaknesses in the planning of projects

117.

The network concept was adopted as a way of fostering multilateral cooperation between the countries on the northern and southern shores of the Mediterranean. Its purpose was both to prevent delays at intergovernmental level and to provide a common workplace for European and southern Mediterranean partnerships, where they could operate on a basis of equality.

118.

The actual execution of a project nevertheless presupposes that all those involved have real legal and financial autonomy. Generally speaking, however, as mentioned in paragraph 114, the governments of the non-member Mediterranean countries supervise their local authorities closely, though to varying extents. The same is true of press freedom. These constraints strongly influence the results that can be expected from programmes such as MED-Urbs and MED-Media. For example, members of the Med-Urbs 29 and Med-Media 15 networks from one southern Mediterranean country were required to obtain the consent of the Ministry of the Interior before they could send even a fax to the network coordinator. From that point of view, the situation of the other MED programmes is less adverse.