, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996

With regard to the impact of the projects, the Commission should obtain more systematic information, based on rigorous evaluations of the results against clearly defined objectives. The nature of many of the actions renders impact measurement difficult, but this makes the evaluation function all the more important. On the basis of the data currently available, and its own observations in the field, the Court considers that the impact of the MED programmes remains to be proven.

Some of the weaknesses in implementation of the programmes stem from inadequacies in the conception of the programmes (e.g. the lack of authority of the network coordinators, limits to the autonomy of the members), from weaknesses in the management instruments (most notably the inapplicability of important clauses in the contract), and from limits on the role given to the Technical Assistance Offices.

Introduction

85.

The audits of documents carried out on the spot in the head offices of the organizations coordinating the 30 selected networks revealed many examples of shortcomings and irregularities. At the same time, irrespective of the necessary slight variations from one programme to another and the caution imposed by the lack of distance, the impact of the funded projects appears overall to be low in quantitative terms and difficult to evaluate in terms of quality.

86.

This situation is not, however, attributable solely to the network managers. The inherent weaknesses in the design of the programmes and the unsuitability of the monitoring and management facilities installed by the Commission and ARTM are also at fault.

Results of audits at network head offices

Findings concerning financial and accounting matters

87.

In addition to stipulating that the budget on which it is based is to be adhered to, the contract concluded between the Commission, the ARTM and every network coordinator:

(a)

sets out the principle that the project is to be co-financed by the Commission and the members of the network;

(b)

specifies that a special bank account is to be opened for the network;

(c)

provides that the accounts for the project are to be separate and in accordance with the standards laid down by ARTM;

(d)

states that supporting documents are to be kept for a period of five years;

(e)

specifies that a set of financial statements is to be annexed to the progress reports.

  • celex=31992R1763