Regularity from the point of view of budgetary principles
Administrative expenditure covered by operating appropriations
Although it is irregular, entrusting the administrative and financial management of the MED programmes to the ARTM constitutes a delegation of the Commission`s powers. Consequently, this agency`s operating costs should have been entirely funded from Part A of the budget, the Commission`s operating expenditure appropriations. Similarly, work on drafting the financing proposals, which was entrusted to external consultants, should also have been financed from Part A. However, an examination of the Commission`s accounts and the contracts awarded to the ARTM and FERE Consultants as part of the implementation of the MED programmes included in Annex 5, shows that:
out of ECU 1 311 136 ECU received by the ARTM as payment, ECU 863 743 was charged by the Commission to operating appropriations under heading B 7-4 0 8 0, although no justification was provided other than the shortage of appropriations available from Part A of the budget;
the same is true as regards financing obtained by consultants recruited to design and draw up preliminary draft financing proposals for the MED-Urbs, MED-Invest and MED-Campus programmes for total payments of ECU 480 160.
This practice marks the reappearance of so-called 'mini-budgets', even though the remarks in the budget which accompany heading B 7-4 0 8 0 explicitly rule out the utilization of appropriations to cover management and administrative expenditure in general.
Infringements of the budgetary principle of universality
In a note dated 3 March 1994, the Commission informed the ARTM that 'interest produced by the Commission`s payments must be specifically deducted from the applications for payment that you send to the Commission'.
This solution is contrary to the budgetary principle of universality. The interest concerned is the product of sums which, until such time as the beneficiary networks have fulfilled the contractual conditions which enable them to demand payment of the subsidy awarded, belong to the Commission.
This interest (see Annex 4), which totalled ECU 707 900 on 31 December 1994, is therefore a revenue item under the general budget of the Community which must be entered as such and must be paid back to the Commission`s Accountant.