, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
75.

In principle, the duration of the operations covered by the MED financing decisions is one year. If the accounts which record the implementation of these decisions had been drawn up on the due date that would have enabled the Commission to regularize its financial accounts. As of mid-July 1995 the Commission and ARTM had not agreed the balances of the accounts for any of the financing decisions and the former had applied to the latter for payment of neither interest nor the available balances on the accounts.

76.

Spending in excess of the annual framework initially provided for is explained by serious delays in the implementation of programmes. Component B of the MED-Invest programme continues to be the case that gives most cause for concern: two years after the adoption of the financing decision, the rate of progress was only 24,8 %.

Protection of the Commission`s financial interests

77.

An examination of the ARTM`s balance sheets shows that the first year of operation generated a loss of ECU 19 706. However, the operations of the second year made it possible to record in the balance sheet adopted in 1994 a profit of ECU 36 224, a sum which included a payment of ECU 74 000 to cover risks and charges.

78.

The ARTM has not returned to the Commission the ECU 51 847 which the latter disbursed when the agency was formed, even though ARTM has refunded to FERE Consultant the 22 700 ECU that it put up for the same purpose.

79.

The ARTM`s Articles of Association stipulate in the event of dissolution that the Management Board shall determine the allocation of the association`s assets. All expenditure on creating and setting up the ARTM was borne by the Commission, which is also the ARTM`s sole backer. Furthermore, the ARTM`s work is totally dependent on the programmes managed by the Commission.

80.

Consequently, the Commission should have taken greater care to ensure its interests were protected by demanding that the sums it had advanced should be reimbursed and by having itself clearly designated in the ARTM`s Articles of Association as the recipient of the ARTM`s asets in the event of dissolution.

Observations concerning selection procedures

Establishment of the Committees