, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
84.

Allowing the Selection Committees the latitude to give a favourable opinion on a network whilst cutting the budget of the proposed project has led to significant delays in execution. As a result ARTM is, in fact, obliged to renegotiate its budget with the network coordinator after the Commission has adopted the financing decision. Under these circumstances, the delays inherent in the selection process, combined with those imposed by the necessity of consulting the MED Committee in advance of the financing decision, make it virtually impossible for projects to be carried out under satisfactory conditions within the one-year framework of these measures. On all the projects that were visited the timetabling constraint was mentioned as one of the main difficulties that had to be overcome when projects were being executed.

PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION

Summary

At the level of the networks and the projects themselves (30 networks were sampled by the Court), a large number of weaknesses and irregularities were identified. These can be summarised as follows:

(a)

concerning financial and accounting matters

–

basic requirements of proper financial management and control of public funds, which were provided for in the contracts between ARTM and the network coordinators, were frequently not respected: this was notably the case with regard to separate accounting for the projects, conservation of supporting documents for expenditure claimed and the opening of a separate bank account for the network,

–

the obligations of network partners to provide a co-financing contribution to the projects have been largely ignored,

–

ineligible expenditure has been financed: in some cases this was systematic (e.g. the reimbursement of the costs of local authority personnel already financed by the budget of the authority), in others it concerned individual cases, which, albeit of limited financial importance, reflected the weaknesses in the system of controls;

(b)

concerning matters of sound financial management:

–

the award of contracts following competitive tendering was the exception rather than the rule,

–

because of its lack of knowledge of national rules, ARTM paid daily allowances and supplementary remuneration at levels exceeding those allowed.