, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
96.

An analysis of financial flows even indicates that for some projects the EC contribution was higher than the real financial outflows (MED-Campus 25, 95, 126, MED-Urbs 34 and MED-Media 6).

Ineligibility of some expenditure

97.

Among the Court`s findings there were certain elements that were systematic whilst others concerned only a small number of networks. The following examples are in the first category.

Reimbursement of staff expenditure

98.

In the context of the MED-Urbs programme local authorities were systematically submitting to ARTM for refund amounts corresponding to the time that their officials and similar staff had spent on implementing the project. The work done by such staff is part of the responsibilities of the authority by which they are employed and is covered by its administrative budget. Although it is conceivable that the Commission might bear part of the cost of additional remuneration as an incentive to staff or to facilitate the recruitment of extra staff so as to cope with an increased workload, declarations for reimbursement, in full, for time spent by national officials must be considered ineligible for Community funding.

99.

Since the authorities concerned were unable to produce any record of authorization for the payment of extra remuneration or the recruitment of the staff assigned to the project, it may be deduced that the Community refunds were, in fact, used to refinance the budgets of the network members concerned.

100.

In this connection, the Court recalls that in September 1992, in the context of the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), the Commission issued a manual of financial procedures, setting out the principles behind Community co-financing of inter-regional cooperation. In that document, in the second sentence of Section 4.2, the Commission stated that the European Community does not take into account as eligible expenditure for co-financing capital expenditure (purchases of machinery, furniture, etc.) or the salaries of permanent officials or staff of local authorities or other organizations.

Absence of supporting documents

101.

In 16 of the 32 transactions selected for the sample, the coordinators were unable to produce any documents in support of the expenditure. Under the rules concerning the use of Community public funds the transactions in question should, therefore, not have been accepted.

Other anomalies identified