The evaluation reports of the first-year pilot phases of MED-Urbs and MED-Media, which were carried out in 1994 (1), both identify key weaknesses in the formulation and prioritizing of the purposes and goals of the programmes, and translating these into specific and concise objectives. Although the evaluation report for MED-Campus did not examine the programme in the same way as the other two (2), concentrating primarily on the way in which the programme had been implemented, there are indications in the report that the same weaknesses applied.
It was, therefore, difficult for the evaluators to measure the impact of the programmes. The MED-Urbs report identified positive results for some of the individual projects it examined, while the MED-Media report concluded that after the first year the impact of the programme had been limited, but that lessons had been learned for the future. The MED-Campus report did not examine the projects themselves.
The Commission has used the results of the three evaluation reports to strengthen the formulation of the programmes and the projects, but at the time of the Court's audit it was too early to see whether this had led to a significantly greater impact for the programmes.
As explained in paragraph 4, the Court`s audit concentrated on the serious irregularities and weaknesses in financial management identified at an early stage of its work. It has, however, found the following in terms of the impact of the measures:
during the first two years of the programmes, when the majority of the network coordinators and the organizations carrying out activities for the networks were located in Europe, the bulk of the funds provided by the Commission were consumed in Europe;
the freedom of operation of certain local authorities within the networks was limited by the absence, in whole or in part, of legal and/or financial autonomy in relation to the central government: the ultimate effectiveness of the actions carried out, particularly where investments are required, depends in such circumstances on obtaining the agreement and support of the central government, which in most cases will not have been involved in the initial action;