, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
126.

ARTM`s structure, size and staff profile are such that it was impossible for it to be aware of all the legal constraints affecting the managers of networks whose members were from different countries of the Union and southern Mediterranean. The Commission, on the other hand, is responsible for checking that any measures which it puts into effect are fully legal. It must be aware of conflicts of legislation and, moreover, it has the necessary powers. That reason alone should have sufficed for it to question, if not the legality then, at least, the validity of the delegation of powers to ARTM.

127.

The fact that the project coordinators signed contracts containing clauses with which they could not comply can undoubtedly be explained partly by the probable unenforceability of the choice of the Brussels civil court as the court to which any disputes are to be referred. In fact, it is not clear whether that court is competent to deal with contracts which concern the implementation of a Community policy where the parties to the contract may include a public-law body in a member country of the European Union.

Weakness of the financial control system

128.

Apart from the unreliability of the financial information that has been discussed above, there was another major weakness in ARTM`s financial monitoring. It is essentially based on a comparison of the expenditure statements forwarded by the network coordinator and the budget documents annexed to the contracts. The two sets of documents have been structured in a way which makes such comparison easy. In fact, in the absence of the supporting documents for the amounts of expenditure shown, the comparison can be used only to form an opinion of their plausibility and cannot be used to establish their existence or accuracy.

The limits of BAT monitoring

129.

The objective of the BATs` involvement was twofold: to assist the networks and to provide the Commission with information concerning the progress of projects. From this point of view, the overall results achieved are mediocre given their cost, although there is some slight variation between programmes. On the other hand, the quality of monitoring for the MED-Avicenne programmes, which is carried out directly by the Commission, is high.

130.

The terms of reference of the contracts concluded with the BATS do not include any obligation to assess the justification for the sums which are the subject of refund applications.

CONCLUSIONS