, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
102.

Cases of the entry in the accounts of other ineligible items of expenditure, although they were not systematic or material in terms of the budget, were nevertheless indicative of weakness in the established control systems.

103.

For example:

(a)

Med-Urbs 30: an amount of ECU 31 705, or 15,5 % of the total Community contribution for the network, was for ineligible expenditure such as a consultant`s charge for drafting a tender prepared for the purpose of obtaining fresh Commission funding (ECU 18 125); the cost of preparing a simple agenda (never updated) and a four-page guide which simply presents the MED programmes, without providing any management aids (ECU 9 350); a legal opinion, of which there was no trace (ECU 4 230); and the refund to the coordinator of expenditure on services that were paid for before the service was actually rendered and before the approval of the municipal council was obtained, although it was required before the contract could be signed;

(b)

MED-Urbs 38: apart from the fact that the only concrete achievement of this network was the introduction of a course for training the municipal staff in a very specific craft (there was no practical follow-up), the expenditure financed was for the preparation and establishment of an accounting system of which the auditors could find no trace (ECU 13 905 ) and the person responsible for the project used the account opened in his name to settle various items of casual expenditure;

(c)

MED-Campus 55: ARTM concluded a contract with a person who exercised control, either directly or through his spouse, of several legal bodies involved in the execution of the project. Two of the organizations shared the same premises, used the same equipment and the books of account were kept by the same person, but almost all the staff were paid by only one of them. This arrangement made it possible for one firm to bill the other without it being possible to verify the existence of numerous services for which refund applications were made to ARTM. Neither ARTM nor the Commission was aware of the situation. Furthermore, there were no worksheets by which to verify the number of days` work performed for the network, even though ARTM was charged at a rate of ECU 745 per man/day. This same network invoiced ECU 12 148 ECU to ARTM for preparing progress reports which were a contractual obligation and were included in its fees.