, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
45.

Another condition stipulated by the Meroni ruling concerns the observance by the authority to which power has been delegated of the same rules as those which apply to the delegating authority. As the Commission is required to exercise its powers in complete independence (2), the ARTM should have done the same. This was not the case, as is shown by the Court`s detection of flagrant examples of confusion of interest, details of which are given in paragraphs 50 to 57. These clear violations call into question the whole system of delegation. The fact is that the Commission, as the delegating authority, is responsible for the actions of the ARTM. To this extent, it was also responsible for preventing these violations. The Commission was given the means of doing this when it co-signed the contracts and bank transfers drawn up by the ARTM.

Rules for awarding public contracts

46.

The ARTM was singlehandedly created and financed from scratch by the Commission. This latter signed a private contract at the end of October 1992 with a firm of consultants totalling ECU 54 000 for the purpose of carrying out a study of the organizational needs of the future agency. The expert seconded by this consultant was subsequently put in charge of operations at the ARTM.

47.

The Commission assigned the administrative and financial management of the MED programmes to this agency by private-treaty contracts from 1992 until December 1993. In July 1994, the ARTM obtained a new contract following an invitation to tender. The table attached as Annex 3 gives the details of the amounts of these contracts and the procedures for awarding them. This situation infringes the rules governing the awarding of public contracts. The Commission issued an invitation to tender only when the conditions of equality between the applicants had definitively ceased to exist, even though that meant squandering the experience acquired over the previous two years. Furthermore, the 'brother' programmes subsequently launched as part of the peace process in the Middle East were also entrusted to the ARTM by private treaty contracts as was the technical monitoring, for example, of a Peace programme concluded by private contract with FERE Consultants on 18 January 1995.

  • celex=31992R1763