, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
88.

These requirements had been substantially ignored by networks. In spite of some rare exceptions (MED-Avicenne 126, MED-Invest B.201, MED-Urbs 3, MED-Media 5 and 6), networks on the whole did not keep separate accounts for projects. The transactions pertaining to the implementation of the subsidized project could not be singled out in the general accounts of the coordinating body, or were absent from them if they had been settled from another network member`s funds. There were five cases - MED-Campus 33, MED-Invest A3.09, MED-Campus 25, MED-Campus 126 and MED-Campus 179 - where no accounts could be produced for inspection.

89.

There were similar findings regarding the opening of a special bank account. In reality this obligation was respected only by those networks which subcontracted project management to an outside organization (usually a non-profit making body). In the case of the MED-Urbs 39/40 network, the bank account was opened in a country other than that of the coordinator, contrary to the provisions of the contract. In addition, there were found to be several instances where the funds had been transferred to a bank account that had been opened in the name of the project leader and to which he had unrestricted access (MED-Campus 126, MED-Campus 179 and MED-Media 6).

90.

As regards the possibility of delegating management from the coordinator to an outside organization, in at least one case, that of the MED-Urbs 01 network, the conditions laid down by national jurisprudence to qualify the practice followed by senior staff of the management association had, in fact, been satisfied.

91.

Furthermore, none of the networks selected for the sample were able to provide supporting documents for all the refund applications submitted to ARTM.

92.

Finally, several wrong entries in the accounts were made. Fees for the MED-Media 29 and MED-Urbs 39/40 networks had been entered as staff expenditure, as had travel expenses and subsistence allowances for the latter network. In the case of MED-Urbs 30, some of the costs resulting from extensive use of consultants were accounted for as personnel expenditure. This had the effect of seriously understating the amount of expenditure on external consultants: when the amount of ECU 33 495 wrongly charged as personnel expenses is added to the ECU 55 807 correctly declared as expenditure on external consultants, the total actually spent under this heading accounts for 22,6 % of the total budget for the network.