, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
104.

The above findings indicate that payments have been made to the projects which were not justified, and which should, therefore, in principle be recovered by the Commission. The total amounts to be recovered, however, can only be assessed after an exhaustive examination at the level of the networks. It is for the Commission to decide how to proceed in this matter.

Observations on sound financial management

Calls for tenders

105.

Contracts were frequently concluded by private treaty, especially within the framework of the MED-Urbs programmes. Furthermore, the network coordinators had no control over the choices made by other network members. In the case of Med-Urbs 31, a member of the network thus imposed contractors on the project leader, without producing evidence of a preceding call for tenders. In the case of the Med-Urbs 30 network, it is arguable that in addition to the accounting error which it represents there was also real misapplication of procedures. From a reading of the progress reports it appears, in fact, that expenditure for external consultants was entered under the heading of staff expenditure.

Amount of subsistence allowances and additional remuneration

106.

The rates of subsistence allowances paid by ARTM were systematically higher than the rates paid and often authorized under the pay scales laid down in the national rules to which the European members of the networks are subject. Consequently, instead of being used to pay for services rendered, the extra amounts paid by ARTM were used to refinance the budget of the coordinating body for the network concerned.

107.

As regards additional remuneration, the observations concerning local authorities apply mutatis mutandis to the universities. In their case the national regulations usually provide that contracts may be concluded with teachers for a number of additional hours of work. The regulations specify the hourly rates and maximum number of extra hours authorized.

108.

ARTM`s misreading of these regulations led it to settle bills that were in excess of these maxima and also (in most cases) greater than the amounts actually received by the beneficiary mentioned in the refund application received.

The viability of the networks