The system for the administration and management of the MED programmes was established with insufficient analysis by the various services of the Commission of what could be done within the existing regulatory framework, and without examining properly the implications of what was being proposed. Thus, basic administrative procedures of the Commission which are designed to ensure that an irregular situation is avoided failed to function correctly (paragraphs 39 to 45).
The structure and procedures of the Commission to oversee and monitor the implementation of the MED programmes, and to exercise control over their decentralized administration, were inadequate and deficient. In part, this was because insufficient resources were available for the task.
Serious confusions of interest developed in the implementation of the MED programmes which the Commission failed to put an end to in a timely manner (paragraphs 50 to 57). The risks of such situations arising were evident from the outset and should have led the Commission to call the system itself into question.
There was excessive recourse to private-treaty contracts, without proper tendering. Private-treaty contracts have permeated the whole structure of the MED programmes. This was one of the elements contributing to the development of conflicts of interest referred to above (paragraphs 46 to 49).
At all levels of the financial management of the MED programmes there are serious shortcomings and irregularities (paragraphs 62 to 63; 64 to 80).
At the level of network coordinators and the projects themselves, basic requirements of proper financial management and control of public funds were frequently not respected, and many of the conditions in the contracts between the Commission, ARTM and the network coordinators have not been respected in part because they are inapplicable under the terms of national law (paragraphs 87 to 108 and 124 to 127).
On the basis of the data currently available and its own observations in the field, the Court considers that the impact of the MED programmes remains to be proven.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The Commission should take immediate action to redesign the manner in which these programmes are formulated, managed and implemented. The Court is, therefore, pleased to note that, in response to the Court`s findings, the Commission intends to take a number of measures which would go in this direction.