, Special Report No 1/96 on the MED programmes together with the Commission's replies

In forcesince 30 May 1996
55.

Furthermore, one BAT which had received financing to implement a project in the context of the implementation of component B of the MED-Invest programme was awarded the contract to monitor this programme before the Commission had even given its opinion on the final implementation report which it had submitted as part of this operation.

56.

Once the Commission had realized the danger of this situation, it asked the managers of the BATs responsible for monitoring to resign from the ARTM`s Management Board. The minutes of the meetings of the Agency`s Management Board show how vigorously those concerned resisted the Commission`s requests. Nearly a year and a half went by before they finally decided to step down, in circumstances which are questionable to say the least. Thus, the minutes of the meeting of 11 October 1994 of the Agency`s Management Board show that the two administrators concerned 'would resign if:

–

FERE Consultants were chosen by the European Commission to provide technical assisance for the MED-Invest programme,

–

[or if] Ismeri Europa were reselected as Technical Assistance Bureau (BAT) for the MED Campus programme'.

Furthermore, both of these managers asked to be able to propose a candidate of their choice to replace them in the event of their resignation. Once all of these conditions were fulfilled, both administrators resigned from the ARTM`s Management Board in April 1995.

57.

In view of the seriousness of these findings, the Court immediately informed the Commission of them, so that it could take appropriate measures and examine, in particular, the need to take legal action against those responsible. At the end of November 1995, the responsible Commission departments informed the Court that they intended not to renew contracts signed with the ARTM when they expired in January 1996 and to wind up the ARTM. They were also minded not to renew contracts signed with the BATs and to open an enquiry so as to establish responsibilities and to examine, in cooperation with the Commission`s Legal Service, whether it was appropriate to take legal action.

Budgetary and financial observations concerning the implementation of the programmes

Rate of implementation of the budget

  • celex=31992R1763