once the Committee had given its approval, the ARTM directly signed (see paragraph 34) private treaty contracts to BATs that were managed by two of its administrators for ECU 547 750 and ECU 748 900 respectively. The first case was a contract dated 14 December 1992 between the ARTM and FERE Consultants. The second case concerned a contract dated 21 December 1992 between the ARTM and Ismeri. In both cases, the signatory managers occupied, when they signed the contract with the ARTM, two of the four administrator posts on the ARTM`s Management Board. It must also be noted that both of the firms to which the aforementioned contracts were awarded took part in the meetings of the Commitment Committee which approved the contracts in question;
in the context of the implementation of the MED-Invest programme, these same two BATs were awarded the contract to carry out two projects even though there was no tender or selection procedure. The sums in question totalled ECU 270 000 ECU in one case and ECU 405 000 ECU in the other;
The risks that such errors might occur were inherent in the logic of the system that the Commission envisaged introducing and in the situations of the various parties involved. Even at the drafting stage, these risks were so evident that the Commission should have called the system into question immediately.
The awarding of the contract to monitor the MED-Urbs programme gave rise to a further confusion of interests. Following the invitation to tender issued during the first quarter of 1994, the Conseil des Communes et Régions d'Europe (CCRE) and the Cités Unies Development (CUD) were instructed to monitor the MED-Urbs programme. The legal status of these two bodies is that of a non-profit-making association, set up, inter alia, for the purpose of defending its members` interests. To award them, as the Commission did, the contract to monitor the implementation of a programme which consists of granting subsidies to regional authorities may place the loyalty which the CCRE/CUD owe contractually to the Commission at odds with their statutory obligations in respect of their principals. This situation may also give rise to unfair discrimination against regional authorities which adhere to neither of these associations, all the more so since they belong to other organizations.