, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

2.18. The Delegations' compliance with DIS procedures was perfectly satisfactory in areas such as approval of contract terms of reference, lists of tenderers, work programmes and contractual clauses, but they neglected other essential aspects of their work. For example, they spent only a small amount of time monitoring project progress, either by means of on-the-spot visits to beneficiaries or by review of reports submitted by consultants. These limited contacts with final beneficiaries considerably reduce the effectiveness of the Delegations in PHARE countries.

The role of the Commission in Brussels

2.19. In April 1991 the Commission in Brussels asked its staff to establish guidelines for programming the use of funds and then to provide support to the Delegations in the identification and monitoring of the various programmes (see paragraph 2.14). In practice the role of the Commission's Brussels staff is much wider. In the case of the work programmes, their involvement duplicates the Delegations' work of checking the technical aspects. Moreover, Commission staff in Brussels are still using centralized procedures to commit part of the funds allocated to DIS countries (see Table 1).

2.20. In December 1995 the Commission published new instructions concerning the respective roles of its Brussels staff and its Delegations. These documents are certainly indicative of progress, but their value is considerably reduced by the continuing lack of job descriptions for Commission Brussels staff. In addition, the reporting lines require further clarification. For example, Heads of Delegation are answerable to the programme director in Directorate General (DG) I A for PHARE matters, and not to the desk officers in the same DG, although it would be logical for them to report to the latter. Regarding the advisers in the Delegations, it is not specified whether, for PHARE operations, they report to the Head of Delegation or to the Commission in Brussels.Furthermore, the Commission does not require Delegations to report on the overall implementation of sectoral programmes.