5.21. As the Commission has not introduced uniform accounting packages in the PMUs, each unit has borne the costs of developing its own system (see paragraphs 4.22 - 4.23). Installation of the financial reporting system which was to enable the Commission to monitor the financial implementation of programmes was delayed and suffered from fundamental weaknesses which expensive intervention (costing more than 900 000 ECU) by consultants has only partially remedied (see paragraphs 4.24 - 4.27). The reliability of the Commission's reporting has been affected as a result (see paragraph 4.28).
5.22. The PHACSY financial reporting system currently used by the Commission for monitoring PMU contracts and payments should be replaced with a system that is better suited to PMU requirements and can be integrated into their accounting systems (see paragraphs 4.25 - 4.28).
5.23. The absence of clearly defined objectives for numerous projects financed by PHARE, combined with the fact that most of the budget is intended for technical assistance with usually not very tangible results makes it all the more difficult to assess how soundly the funds have been spent (see paragraph 4.30). After six years of the PHARE programme the Commission was still in the process of establishing an evaluation system. It is important for programme results to be evaluated carefully, particularly as the system in question is a decentralized system over which the Commission has limited direct control. The problems with the system for the annual evaluation of projects (see paragraphs 4.32 and 4.34) have resulted in a lack of clear evidence of how far individual programmes have achieved their objectives. This being the case, the utilization of PHARE funds lacks transparency. The division of responsibilities for evaluation within the Commission should be clarified. Each sectoral programme should be evaluated systematically (see paragraphs 4.29 - 4.34).
General conclusion