4.26. In 1994 the Commission hired consultants to resolve these problems in the system's operation, at a cost of 614 200 ECU, but the results of this initial work were far from satisfactory and a further contract for 188 770 ECU was concluded with new consultants in 1995. 900 000 ECU in total has thus been spent on consultancy contracts in an attempt to improve PHACSY. However, the underlying weaknesses of the system remained such that at the end of 1995 the Commission was considering replacing PHACSY with a new system. In this context it is perhaps worth pointing out that other Commission departments (and DG VIII in particular) already have accounting systems which allow them to monitor the progress of every financing agreement, contract by contract and payment by payment, and that some of these systems are decentralized and located at the Delegations.
4.27. Internal control of DIS has suffered as a result of the low reliability of the data in PHACSY. The PHACSY data are incomplete because several management units have not regularly reconciled their data with the bank statements. Delays in providing the Commission with PHACSY reports have been a further source of problems. In June 1995 38% of PMUs had not reported within the last month, while 15% had not reported for three months. In Slovakia the figures were 57% and 29% respectively. Delays in submitting reports had been cut substantially in the second half of 1995.
4.28. The problems with the reliability and timeliness of PHACSY have seriously affected the external reporting on the PHARE programme, especially as regards the quarterly reports to the European Parliament on PHARE financial implementation. Until the recent improvement in reporting times the values of local contracts were substantially understated. In the reports in question the analysis of contracting is by year. This practice is confusing, because the figures refer to the year in which the contracts were accounted for in PHACSY, rather than the year in which they were concluded. As the introduction of PHACSY did not begin until 1992 and actual installation in PMUs was substantially delayed, the backlog in entering data was not finally cleared until 1995.
Reports on the effectiveness of measures