3.21. In this area, several shortcomings were noted in respect of the Commission, which did not define what is meant by 'operating expenditure`, did not specify the length of the 'start-up stage` and did not adopt a rule for applying the principle of degressivity (21).
3.22. This lack of an overall policy and of guidelines applicable to the financing of the operating expenditure of the PHARE programme led the Commission to adopt an ad hoc approach. Only in mid-1995 did the Commission commission a study on the organization of the PMUs. This study covered around a hundred PMUs and showed that the units had an average staff of nine or ten people, 57 % of whom were paid by PHARE. These staff financed by PHARE were in turn composed of an average of 1,2 foreign experts and 4,2 local employees. Table 8 gives a detailed analysis of the situation in mid-1995.
>TABLE>
3.23. In Poland, the main beneficiary of PHARE, the PMUs are both numerous and large and have a total staff of 430 (of whom 87% are paid by PHARE), including foreign experts. In addition, in 60 % of these PMUs' salary costs are totally borne by PHARE. Owing to their dependence on PHARE financing, the ultimate viability of these PMUs, half of which are foundations (see paragraph 3.9), is not guaranteed. In this country, the two PMUs that received the most PHARE aid for the payment of staff salaries were:
the Polish Agency for Regional Development (PARD), responsible for the important STRUDER programme (22) (76,7 Mio ECU): its 90 local members of staff were paid by the PHARE programme, i.e. 625 000 ECU in 1995;
the Foundation for Assistance to Agricultural Programmes (FAAP): 49 out of 53 local members of staff were paid by the PHARE programme, i.e. 600 000 ECU in 1995.
3.24. In the other countries, although the proportion of PMU staff expenditure financed by PHARE was smaller, it was still between 35% and 55%. The cases below are examples of PMUs where the PHARE financing was particularly high:
the Foundation for International Management (FIMAN) and the Programme Management Unit responsible for education in Romania, where 32 out of a total of 33 local members of staff were financed by PHARE in 1995 (350 000 ECU);
the programme management unit of the Bulgarian Ministry of Industry, the seven local employees of which were financed by the PHARE programme (35 000 ECU in 1995).