, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

3.5. The advantage of the principle of decentralization is that it makes beneficiary countries participate in the management of PHARE funds. In practice, however, the quality of the services provided by PMUs has varied considerably. In all cases, a learning process was established in respect of PHARE procedures and, more broadly, methods for managing public funds. This learning process often had negative effects on the programmes and resulted, in particular, in delays in implementation (see paragraphs 2.8 - 2.10) and difficulties as regards contracting (see paragraphs 4.6 - 4.9), financial management (see paragraphs 4.14 - 4.21) and the mechanisms for drafting implementation reports (see paragraph 4.27).

3.6. The increase in the number of PMUs could have had a positive impact, insofar as it created more opportunities for the transfer of know-how. However, in practice, the development of management powers often proved to be a delicate matter. The fact is that, although the PMUs played an important bridging role between the Commission and the ministries concerned in the early years, they were often poorly integrated within the ministries. This lack of integration reduced the transfer of know-how and led to programme management units being distanced from national policies and priorities.

3.7. Although the programme management units did serve as an intermediary for the national administrations it would have been preferable to view them as a temporary solution until the reform of public authorities and the experience gained by the Commission made it possible to integrate the PHARE programme completely into the work of the national ministries. Not only did the Commission not pursue a strategy of progressive integration of the PMUs' work into that of the national authorities, but the beneficiary countries did not give sufficient priority at the beginning of the PHARE programme to the reform of public administration either.