, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

4.23. Article 16 of the PHARE 'General conditions relating to financing memorandum` requires beneficiaries to 'maintain records and accounts adequate to identify the works, supplies or services financed under the financing memorandum in accordance with sound accounting procedures`. The keeping of reliable accounts is essential if control is to be carried out on an ex post basis. Accounting has proved problematic for PMUs in PHARE countries due not only to a lack of knowledge of financial management techniques but also the inadequacy of the practical guidelines and training supplied by the Commission. Every technical assistance group in the management units has set up its own accounting system, resulting in duplication of effort in one PHARE country after the other. Moreover, the systems introduced were seldom based on the principles of double-entry book-keeping. It is difficult to employ identical computerized accounting systems in every country because of differences in legal and accounting procedures. Nevertheless, it would have been possible to organize a common core for all PHARE programmes at national level in conjunction with national coordinators, and thus ensure a certain minimum level of consistency.

4.24. In the early years of the PHARE programme the Commission did not pay sufficient attention to financial reporting and the establishment of reliable accounting systems, and the DIS is still suffering the consequences of that omission. It was not until 1992 that a common computer system (PHACSY) began to be introduced in management units. The 1994 DIS manual stated that 'as far as accounting is concerned, the PMU will operate and keep a detailed account of all transactions undertaken during the programme term; this is to be done through PHACSY, the reporting system set up for this purpose by the Commission`. In practice the system is used only for financial reporting, as it has not proved adequate for accounting purposes.

4.25. PHACSY is unnecessarily complex for the relatively simple task required of it, namely monthly reporting to the Commission on local contracting and disbursements, and is of limited use for providing detailed management information. It does not meet the PMUs' requirements, because it was not developed in consultation with them, and it has caused duplication of work, in that data have to be entered in the PMUs' accounting systems and then in PHACSY separately.