, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

The Commission gave preference to Article 118 of the Financial Regulation when it decided that service contracts worth more than 50 000 ECU would be subject to restricted invitation to tender. As a result, access was not always 'on equal terms`, as required by Article 7 of the PHARE Regulation.

4.3. Despite the importance attached to compliance with the principle of competitive tendering, the Commission in Brussels does not have a system to check in a global manner whether the principle was being applied by the delegations. An examination by the Court of shortlists concerning 320 invitations to tender in 1993 and 1994 showed that, depending on the PHARE countries concerned, companies from certain Member States were chosen from the lists more often than companies from other countries. In some PHARE countries, the tendency to defer the requirement for 'reasonable geographical balance` (26) is particularly notable. Indeed, companies with offices in Poland and Hungary are by far the most frequently consulted (see Table 9).

>TABLE>

4.4. The frequency with which companies are chosen from the lists is also lacking in balance. Out of 1 102 companies invited to tender for the 320 contracts examined, 818 (i.e. approximately three-quarters) were consulted only once. On the other hand, a small group of 24 companies, i.e. 3 % of the total, were selected between 10 and 31 times (see Table 10).

>TABLE>

4.5. The most important aspect of restricted invitations to tender is the drawing-up of lists of companies which are invited to submit a bid (see paragraph 3.33). Under the decentralized system, PMUs are responsible for drawing up lists that are subsequently submitted to the Commission. The initial guidelines drafted in 1990 were particularly vague about the procedures for drawing up such lists, as they stated only that the Authorising Officer for the programmes would ensure that appropriate measures were taken to encourage broad participation in invitations to tenders and contracts. The 1994 manual on public contracts under a decentralized system confirmed the need to provide a 'reasonable geographical balance` and indicated certain criteria to be taken into account (27).