3.33. Although contracts to provide PMUs with technical assistance are concluded by means of a tendering procedure, the element of competition involved in this procedure does not always lead to lower expenditure. In the first instance, when tenders are being examined, the Commission emphasizes the technical quality of the tenders that it has received. The financial assessment subsequently counts for only 30% of the total assessment and companies' tenders are examined only if the technical assessment is above a certain threshold (25). This use of shortlists reduces price competition. Moreover, competition, which is measured in terms of the number of tenders received, is generally low when measured against the size of the contracts in question. For example, out of a sample of 35 invitations to tender to provide PMUs with technical assistance, the average number of tenders received was only 4,4 for every 7,6 companies invited to submit bids. The reason most commonly cited to explain the difference between the number of bids sought and the number of bids received is that companies placed on the shortlist of tenderers join forces to submit a joint bid. This practice is encouraged by the Commission, which issues a list of all short-listed companies when the invitation to tender is issued. The small number of tenders received in turn affects the number of tenders in respect of which a financing proposal is examined (an average of just 2,1 financing proposals were examined per contract). For 29 % of invitations to tender, only one financing proposal was examined. In such cases there is no price competition at all.
3.34. The initial duration of nearly 90 % of contracts for providing technical assistance to PMUs was extended at least once. The median increase in the value of contracts as a result of these extensions was 67 %. The following cases serve to illustrate this phenomenon:
in the case of the management unit responsible for agriculture in Hungary, the initial contract (value 0,6 Mio ECU) that was concluded in October 1990 for a period of 15 months was extended on three occasions until July 1995; the value of the amendments totalled 2,3 Mio ECU. Only on this latter date was a new invitation to tender issued in respect of an additional contract worth 1 Mio ECU;