, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

5.2. The Commission gave high priority to fully committing the PHARE annual budget, and was successful in that aim (see paragraph 2.2). However, contracting and disbursement of funds have not been accomplished at the same rate. The decentralized procedures have slowed down, rather than accelerated, the award of contracts (see paragraph 2.2). The Commission's reporting of disbursement rates does not reflect the real expenditure situation, in that there was an outstanding balance of 497 Mio ECU (i.e. 38% of the funds channelled through the DIS) on deposit in PMU bank accounts at 31 December 1995 (see paragraph 2.3).

5.3. Various factors affecting the PHARE programme as a whole and certain aspects of the DIS itself have impeded the progress of these measures. They include:

(a)

the fact that the Commission did not make sufficient staff available for the PHARE programme during the start-up phase in 1990 (see paragraph 2.5);

(b)

the low absorptive capacity of the beneficiary countries (see paragraph 2.5);

(c)

the undue emphasis given to full commitment of the annual budget (see paragraph 2.2), which mobilized resources at the expense of the preparation of individual projects;

(d)

insufficient limitation of the number of programmes, projects and contracts in the light of the limited staff resources available at the Commission in Brussels (see paragraph 2.7).

As for the DIS itself, there have been significant delays in the submission and approval of work programmes and contracts by Commission headquarters (see paragraphs 2.10 - 2.12).

5.4. The problems that were found reflect shortcomings in the Commission's supervision of the DIS. Decentralization to the Commission Delegations has only been partial, with the Brussels-based departments continuing to play a major part in day-to-day management (see paragraphs 2.19 - 2.22). The Delegations have suffered from staff shortages (see paragraphs 2.15 - 2.17) and delays in filling posts.

609(01).1

5.5. The Delegations should be made fully responsible for the day-to-day monitoring of PHARE measures, which was the principle adopted originally. However, Delegation staffing will have to be strengthened, with financial and contract management specialists in particular, if all work programmes and contracts are to be approved by them (see paragraph 2.22). Redeployment of staff from PHARE headquarters and other Delegations to the Delegations that have been opened in PHARE countries should be speeded up.