4.11. Under the DIS, payments are made by PMUs without any prior checks being carried out by the Commission (29). This very significant decentralization measure was adopted by the Commission even though it had no particular information on the inspections that are carried out at government level in the beneficiary countries or on the procedures established by the PMUs. However, standards of management and financial control vary considerably from one management unit to another and, in many cases, basic administrative checks in respect of the separation of duties, the countersigning of payment orders and comparisons of banking data had not been made. Furthermore, the Commission gave no clear instructions to the PMUs in this connection and even the 1994 manual deals only summarily with administrative and financial inspection procedures.
4.12. The Commission's checking of expenditure in respect of the decentralized system consisted of:
examining work programmes prior to adoption;
checking the terms of reference and the invitation-to-tender files;
checking contract awards and the related files, including the terms of payment: after signing in the case of contracts below 150 000 ECU and before signing for contracts above this threshold;
ex post accounting checks, which were entrusted to independent audit firms, in respect of the various programmes.
4.13. Although the Commission's 1990 guidelines provided for twice-yearly audits of the programmes, these audits were carried out on an ad hoc and limited basis between 1990 and the end of 1994. Thus, the fact that before 1995, only 34 of the 108 PHARE programmes financed from 1990 to 1992 had been audited constitutes a serious weakness in the Commission's inspection system. However, a significant improvement has been noted since early 1995 and programmes are now regularly audited at the half-way stage, on the scheduled expiry date and upon closure. As of mid-1996, however, little use had been made of the findings of these audits.
4.14. One significant weakness nevertheless remains in the procedures concerning payments to consultants. The PMUs did not systematically check that the consultant had actually worked the number of days stated in the contract. This is an area which is, at the very least, lacking in transparency.