, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

3.25. The lack of clear rules concerning operating expenditure may also hamper the implementation of individual programmes. For example, in Poland, the approval of the work programmes relating to the 1991 privatization programme (50 Mio ECU) was delayed in 1994 while the Commission reviewed the principle and extent of the funding for the salaries of the staff in the PMU and the ministry concerned. In this country uncertainty over future PHARE financing also contributed to high staff turnover.

3.26. The Commission proposed solving the problem of salary levels (see paragraph 3.8) by allowing the salaries of PMU staff to be topped up with PHARE funds, subject to the official agreement of the national administrations. This method was not adopted because of the tensions that large differences in salary might create within the national administrations. However, many PMUs top up salaries indirectly, for example by paying daily allowances to staff in respect of official travel. These daily allowances, which are calculated on the basis of United Nations' scales, are particularly high when compared with average monthly salaries. For example, in Romania, where the monthly salary of PMU directors was around 90 ECU in 1995, the daily allowance amounted to 224 ECU.

3.27. In addition to the financing of PMU staff expenditure, PHARE funds often covered purchases of vehicles and office equipment, as well as operating expenditure (telecommunications, fuel and maintenance of vehicles, rent, heating and electricity charges). The amount of PHARE financing in these areas is difficult to determine because of the lack of clear accounting for such expenditure. The study of the PMUs carried out by the Commission in 1995 cannot be regarded as reliable, insofar as it was based only on management unit declarations. However, it is clear that, in the case of certain management units, investment expenditure and operating expenditure (excluding salaries) were considerable. For example, the annual operating costs, excluding salaries, of the PMUs responsible for the three main PHARE activities in Poland (privatization, agriculture and regional development) were estimated at approximately 1,1 Mio ECU in 1995 by the expert assigned to carry out the study by the Commission.