, Special Report No 3/97 concerning the decentralized system for the implementation of the…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1997

3.17. A large part of the job of drafting the manual distributed in 1994 was entrusted to a firm of consultants whose contract was concluded by direct negotiation in January 1993, although the value of the contract (59 581 ECU) exceeded the 50 000 ECU threshold authorized for contracts of this nature. Whilst work was scheduled to start in October 1992 and the manual was due to be completed in March 1993, the consultants continued to work until March 1994 and their total remuneration came to 212 634 ECU.

3.18. When the incomplete version of the manual was published in the PHARE countries in mid-1994, the Commission organized a week of DIS training in each country. Once this limited action had been taken, the Commission organized only a few periods of supplementary training on the DIS procedures. No Brussels-based Commission official was instructed to organize DIS training within the PMUs, and the Delegations, for their part, did not have enough time to ensure that the PMU staff's skills were upgraded on the job.

Financial costs of the management units

3.19. The costs of the PMUs are divided between the PHARE programme and the beneficiary countries. However, it is impossible to know the exact cost to the PHARE countries because the financing agreements do not require them to declare their financial contributions to each programme. It is also impossible to establish which PMU costs are charged to the PHARE programme itself because the Commission has not created a sufficiently precise accounting framework for recording these costs. Indeed, it is not possible from the Commission's accounts to identify separately the PMUs' administrative costs, the technical assistance costs for administrative support and the technical assistance costs for operational support (see paragraph 3.10). Moreover, the nomenclature used varies from one sectoral programme to another.

Management units' operating costs

3.20. The budgetary constraints experienced by the PHARE countries (see paragraph 3.8), together with the proliferation of PMUs (see paragraph 3.4), put such pressure on the Commission that it contributed to the financing of the PMUs' operating expenditure, even though the PHARE Regulation (Article 6) restricted the financing of this expenditure:

'Maintenance and operating costs may be covered for training and research programmes and for other projects; however, for the latter such costs may be covered only in the start-up stage and shall be degressive`.